Poll: Where Should Carlos Beltran Bat In Cardinals Lineup?

Earlier this week, the St. Louis Cardinals and general manager John Mozeliak did their very best to replace the departed Albert Pujols by signing switch-hitting outfielder Carlos Beltran to a two year, $26 million contract. 

Beltran, who is 34 and has had a myriad of injuries the past several seasons, is among the best hitters in the game when healthy.  Beltran hit .300 with 22 home runs, 84 RBI's and 71 walks while playing for the New York Mets and San Francisco Giants in 2011.  It was Beltran's best season in quite some time.  

Now that Beltran has signed on to play with the Cardinals for the next two seasons, the question is, where does he hit in the Cardinals still very potent lineup?  

Take a look at the breakdown by where Beltran has hit in the lineup throughout his career.

ISplitGHRRBIBAOBPOPS
Batting 1st1031161.282.314.744
Batting 2nd23149155.293.378.926
Batting 3rd957173639.279.356.854
Batting 4th28147194.293.378.891
Batting 5th1081165.286.382.805
Batting 6th32210.229.325.610
Batting 7th36821.310.360.963
Batting 8th500.500.6001.100
Batting 9th1511.214.313.813
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 12/24/2011.

Beltran has clearly spent more time batting in the three hole throughout his career, more than any place in the lineup.  If Beltran hits third, he would just take Pujols's vacant spot in the lineup and everybody else's roles would remain the same. 

But according to some, new manager Mike Matheny has hinted that he would like to hit Beltran second, which would match the mindset of predecesor Tony La Russa who liked to have some "pop" hitting second in the lineup.

The numbers would seem to support Matheny.  With less games played while hitting second, Beltran has a higher batting average, on base percentage, and OPS while hitting second in the lineup.  That being said, he is still very good as a number three hitter as well.  

So where should Beltran hit in the Cardinals lineup?  Vote now and leave your comments below.  





Sources:



Comments